Hacker Newsnew | past | comments | ask | show | jobs | submitlogin

Change title from 'Police' to 'State Police in Victoria, Australia' please. Title is misleading/linkbaity.


Sorry mate, but Victoria is not a 'small Australian city'.

http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Victoria_(Australia)


Victoria isn't a city at all, it's a state. But it's the Mildura police that issued this warning. Mildura is certainly a small town.


Without this degenerating into an argument over semantics, by that line of reasoning any police officer would simply be a 'police officer in a small neighbourhood police station' no matter how large the police body is. The warning was issued by Victoria Police members and is on the Victoria Police website, I don't see there being any issue with its credibility.


Mildura has a population over 30,000, so it's not a small town.


There is no problem with the credibility of the article - the problem is with the sensationalist/linkbaiting headline. Most people are going to assume upon reading the title that 'Police' refers to something a bit more substantial than the police force of Mildura, Australia.


They represent the state police force as a whole.


Australia doesn't have "city police", they are all State (or Territory) Police.


Issued by the Victoria State Police, presiding over 227,600 km2

About the same area as England, Wales and Scotland.

Also slightly larger than the "Small American city" of Utah.


Fair enough, so it can be changed to 'State Police in Victoria, Australia' or similar.


Why? Lest people mistakenly think that the headline is referring to the organization of all police on the globe ever?

When you see a news article about "Police say [whatever]" it is assumed that a particular organization is saying it. There isn't a global organization of police for it to be confused with.


When we refer to "police" in Australia it's 99% of the time state police. Federal police make up the rest as that typically won't come up in conversation as they deal with international issues.


Ok well as an American when I think of 'police' I do not think of Australian police - State or otherwise.


That is probably your problem rather than the submitter's problem.


Based on your previous posts I would have accused you of that. But, lo, you just said it yourself.


Hacker News is international you know?


I read the headline as "Some police somewhere", not as "All police in Australia".

I'm aware of the 80 char limit on subject lines, and I realise that sometimes information is left out.

Your suggestion is 28 characters more than "Police ".


Notice how TechCrunch (and every other publication that picked up this story) worded it:

http://i.imgur.com/C5how.png

Australian Police is infinitely less misleading and more accurate than simply saying 'police'. I have to assume all of these downvotes I've received are from Australians or other foreigners making some kind of anti-American point. The fact remains - this is a US owned website and a topic about a US company. Saying 'Police' gives the impression it is American police - when it isn't.


> I have to assume all of these downvotes [...]

HN has an international audience. Assuming that $THING defaults to $US_VERSION_OF_THING is suboptimal. It's silly to do it here, it's silly to do it with dates; it's silly to do it with anything.

If you'd said that explicit declaration of nationality is better because it makes things clearer and easier to grok then you'd have got upvotes. But because you assumed US police and attacked the title as link baity you got downvotes.


On the contrary, "Police" NOS no more means "American Police" than ".com" means "US commercial website". Similarly, from an international perspective, Apple is an Irish company. If you don't believe me, ask your local tax authority.




Guidelines | FAQ | Lists | API | Security | Legal | Apply to YC | Contact

Search: