> On the allocation happy path there is literally less work in case of Java
Doing more allocations isn't "less work". No matter how many times you mumble "But it's just a pointer bump" the alternative was no work.
> it has chosen different tradeoffs
Sure, it's easier to implement this, the New Jersey style. But that's not a benefit to anybody else, so if you're not Sun Microsystems (which you aren't, Sun no longer exists) then that's not actually a benefit at all and this was a bad trade.
Which is why people have expended an eyewatering amount of effort on Project Valhalla to some day fix this stuff.
Doing more allocations isn't "less work". No matter how many times you mumble "But it's just a pointer bump" the alternative was no work.
> it has chosen different tradeoffs
Sure, it's easier to implement this, the New Jersey style. But that's not a benefit to anybody else, so if you're not Sun Microsystems (which you aren't, Sun no longer exists) then that's not actually a benefit at all and this was a bad trade.
Which is why people have expended an eyewatering amount of effort on Project Valhalla to some day fix this stuff.