I do not see how. A well made guitar from a factory would give the same joy as a hand made one as far as I am concerned. Perhaps even more upon realizing imperfections were avoided.
You two are in a battle over aesthetics, it is a battle that neither of you can win.
There is something attractive about a new set of work gloves. They are fresh, clean, almost begging you to use them in a project.
There is something attractive about a set of work gloves that have curled to the shape of your hands and have been burnished by sap and sawdusts and oils: come on old friend, let's remake our previous magic.
There's something nice about a fleecy throw, but they are not as cozy as the quilts my wife made for my daughter, but defining that coziness will remain out of reach as far as my words go.
No one can be correct, here. It's just what appeals more or less to you.